Museum of American Exceptionalism
← Invention

Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston · 16 October 1846 · Morton, Warren and Gilbert Abbott

This Is No Humbug

A Boston dentist held a glass globe of ether to a young man’s face, and the city’s senior surgeon picked up his knife. Within weeks the world knew surgery no longer had to hurt.

The First Operation Under Ether, Robert C. Hinckley’s painting of the 16 October 1846 operation in the Ether Dome, made between 1882 and 1893.

The moment · Friday morning · 16 October 1846

Gilbert Abbott, 21, sits in the operating chair under the dome. Morton holds the glass globe to his mouth. After four or five minutes Abbott seems asleep. Warren cuts beneath his jaw. Abbott does not shrink or cry out. The first public trial of ether in surgery is under way.

Gentlemen, this is no humbug.John Collins Warren, as first reported in 1859
The First Operation Under Ether, Robert C. Hinckley’s painting of the 16 October 1846 operation in the Ether Dome, made between 1882 and 1893.. Robert C. Hinckley / Countway Library of Medicine, Harvard.
4–5 minof ether before Abbott seemed asleep
33 daysfrom the operation to the medical journals
66 daysfor ether to reach a London operating room
80,000+Union operations under anesthesia in the Civil War

Before 1846, surgery meant lying awake while the knife did its work. Patients put it off until they had no choice, and surgeons were prized for speed. In the fall of that year a 27-year-old Boston dentist offered a vapor he said would stop the pain. The hospital’s senior surgeon agreed to try it, in public, in front of his colleagues.

  1. A tooth pulled in his sleep

    Dentist William Morton has learned from the chemist Charles T. Jackson that sulfuric ether can deaden feeling. Toward evening a Boston man named Eben Frost comes in with an aching tooth and wants it out. Morton soaks his handkerchief in ether and has Frost breathe it. He pulls a firmly rooted bicuspid. Frost comes around within a minute and knows nothing of what was done.

  2. An invitation

    Morton asks John Collins Warren, the hospital’s first surgeon, for a chance to prove his method. Warren satisfies himself the vapor is harmless and agrees. House surgeon Charles Heywood writes to Morton at Warren’s request and asks him to come on Friday. The patient is Gilbert Abbott, 21, admitted on 25 September with a mass under his left jaw that he has carried since birth.

  3. The glass globe

    A handkerchief works for a tooth. Surgery needs more. With advice from the physician Augustus Gould, in whose home he boards, Morton orders an inhaler from a glassmaker: a glass globe holding sponges soaked in ether, with a valved mouthpiece so the patient breathes in vapor and breathes out into the room. It is not ready on time. In the theater the doctors wait, and some think he will not come. Then Morton walks in with it.

    A replica of Morton’s ether inhaler: a glass globe holding sponges soaked in ether, breathed through the mouthpiece.
    A replica of Morton’s ether inhaler: a glass globe holding sponges soaked in ether, breathed through the mouthpiece.. Wellcome Collection.
  4. Under the dome

    Abbott breathes from the globe for four or five minutes and seems to fall asleep. Warren makes an incision of about three inches beneath the jaw, finds a tangle of veins and ties it off with a ligature. Abbott does not shrink or cry out at the cut. Near the end he stirs and mutters. Afterward he tells Warren he felt no pain, only something like a blunt instrument scraping his neck.

    Warren to the gallery, as first reported in 1859Gentlemen, this is no humbug.
  5. Complete success

    The next day the vapor is given again, and this time surgeon George Hayward wields the knife. He removes a large fatty tumor from a woman’s upper arm in four or five minutes. When she wakes she says she felt no pain and knew nothing of the operation. Her only worry was for a child she had left at home. Bigelow writes that no one who saw it doubted the unconsciousness was real.

  6. The leg

    Now the real test. Alice Mohan, a young woman with a diseased knee, needs her right leg taken off above the knee. She protests that the vapor is too sharp to breathe, then goes under in about five minutes. Hayward amputates. She remembers nothing of the incision, and when Bigelow asks her afterward, she cannot say whether the leg is gone. It is the first major operation done under ether.

    Henry Jacob Bigelow, 18 November 1846Two recent cases serve to confirm, and one I think to decide, the great utility of this process.
  7. The news goes out

    Henry Jacob Bigelow, a 28-year-old surgeon who watched the first operations, reads a paper on them to the Boston Society for Medical Improvement on 9 November. On the 18th the Boston Medical and Surgical Journal prints it. It is the world’s first formal report of surgical anesthesia. Three days later Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes writes to Morton and suggests a name for the new state: anaesthesia.

  8. Gone round the world

    On 3 December the steamer Acadia leaves Boston carrying letters about the discovery. Bigelow’s father, Dr. Jacob Bigelow, has written to Dr. Francis Boott in London. On 19 December a London dentist, James Robinson, pulls a woman’s molar under ether. On 21 December surgeon Robert Liston amputates the leg of Frederick Churchill at University College Hospital. Churchill feels nothing. Within a year, surgeons in many countries are using ether.

The men in the theater

William T. G. Morton, the Boston dentist who gave the ether, in a lithograph by Sharp, Peirce & Co., Boston.Age 27
Dentist who gave the etherWilliam T. G. Morton

Born in Charlton, Massachusetts, he studied at the Baltimore College of Dental Surgery and opened a practice in Boston. He built the inhaler and put Gilbert Abbott under. In the Civil War he gave ether to the wounded at Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville and Spotsylvania.

Dr. John Collins Warren, pastel by Francis Alexander, about 1845–1850.Age 68
Surgeon, Massachusetts General HospitalJohn Collins Warren

Boston surgeon trained at Edinburgh, co-founder and first surgeon of Massachusetts General Hospital, first dean of Harvard Medical School and co-founder in 1812 of the journal now called the New England Journal of Medicine. He staked his name on an untried vapor and operated.

Dr. Henry Jacob Bigelow, daguerreotype, about 1854.Age 28
Surgeon who told the worldHenry Jacob Bigelow

Young Boston surgeon who watched the first operations, pressed for more and wrote them up. His 1846 paper was voted the most important article in two centuries of the New England Journal of Medicine. He later became Harvard’s professor of surgery.

Dr. George Hayward, photographed about 1860.Age 55
Surgeon, Massachusetts General HospitalGeorge Hayward

Harvard’s first professor of clinical surgery. He performed the second operation under ether the day after Ether Day, then on 7 November the first major one, amputating Alice Mohan’s leg while she slept. It settled the question for good.

By the numbers

1821year the operating theater under the dome opened; it served until 1867
30 Sept 1846Morton pulls Eben Frost’s tooth under ether in his office
21age of Gilbert Abbott, the patient under the dome
4operations under ether in the theater that Bigelow reported to the world
18 Nov 1846Bigelow’s report appears in the Boston Medical and Surgical Journal
21 Nov 1846Oliver Wendell Holmes proposes the word “anaesthesia”
1868Boston raises the Ether Monument, the Public Garden’s oldest
1965the Ether Dome becomes a National Historic Landmark

Watch, listen, see

Films, photographs and first-hand accounts from across the web. Each opens in a new tab.

“It has long been an important problem in medical science to devise some method of mitigating the pain of surgical operations. An efficient agent for this purpose has at length been discovered.”

Henry Jacob Bigelow, Boston Medical and Surgical Journal, 18 November 1846

After

Within a year ether was in use across Europe and beyond. In the spring of 1847 Warren brought the Boston daguerreotypists Southworth and Hawes into the theater, and they made the first photographs of live operations. By the end of the Civil War, Union surgeons had done at least 80,000 operations under anesthesia. Morton went to the front himself and gave ether to the wounded in the field hospitals.

In Jefferson, Georgia, Dr. Crawford Long had removed a tumor from a patient’s neck under ether on 30 March 1842, though he did not publish it until 1849. Boston’s public demonstration is the one that reached the world. Both men were Americans.

In 1868 Boston raised the Ether Monument in the Public Garden. Morton died that same year, at 48, and lies at Mount Auburn Cemetery under an epitaph saying that before him, surgery had always been agony. The old operating theater, now the Ether Dome, became a National Historic Landmark in 1965 and is still a lecture hall. Every 16 October, Boston keeps Ether Day.

Primary sources

  1. 1721InventionSmallpox InoculationDr. Zabdiel Boylston inoculated Boston against smallpox in 1721, and his careful count of every patient showed the method saved lives.1 in 40died after inoculation, vs. 1 in 7 naturally
  2. Rows of iron lungs breathe for polio patients in a hospital ward, about 1953.
    1955InventionThe Polio VaccineJonas Salk’s vaccine was tested on nearly two million schoolchildren, declared safe and effective, and never patented.1.8Mchildren in the trial
  3. Wounded men of the 16th Infantry Regiment wait at the foot of the chalk cliffs on Omaha Beach for evacuation to a field hospital, 6 June 1944.
    1944Arsenal of DemocracyPenicillin for D-DayBritain discovered penicillin but made it by the spoonful. Peoria scientists and 21 American companies had 2.3 million doses ready for D-Day.2.3Mdoses by D-Day
  4. Franklin’s kite experiment in a thunderstorm, with a son beside him: Currier & Ives lithograph, 1876
    1752InventionFranklin and the Lightning RodFranklin proposed the test, a kite repeated it in a Philadelphia storm, and a few feet of iron rod gave every house a way to survive lightning.6–8 ftof iron rod to save a house

Free, with no ads. Support the museum →