Museum of American Exceptionalism
← Liberty

New York · 4 August 1735 · A printer, a lawyer and a jury

The Cause of Liberty

A German-born printer sat in a New York jail for more than eight months for printing the truth about his governor. A Philadelphia lawyer told twelve citizens it was their right to say so.

The courtroom at the Zenger trial, New York, 4 August 1735, in an illustration titled "The Famous Zenger Trial" from Wall Street in History (1883).

The moment · 4 August 1735 · City Hall, Wall Street

The judge says the jury may decide only whether Zenger printed the papers. Andrew Hamilton does not wait. He turns from the bench to the twelve men in the box and tells them the case is bigger than one printer. It reaches every free man in America.

It is the best cause. It is the cause of liberty.Andrew Hamilton
The courtroom at the Zenger trial, New York, 4 August 1735, in an illustration titled "The Famous Zenger Trial" from Wall Street in History (1883).. Martha J. Lamb, Wall Street in History (1883).
8 mo+Zenger in jail before trial
£400bail set for a printer
12jurors in the box
37Zenger’s age

In 1733 a few New Yorkers started a newspaper to say what they thought of their royal governor. The governor jailed the printer. English law held that a printed insult to an official was a crime whether or not it was true. The printer’s lawyers were thrown out of court, and a famous lawyer came up from Philadelphia. He made the case to the jury, and the jury decided.

  1. A governor arrives

    William Cosby lands in New York in 1732 as the new royal governor. He demands half of the salary that Rip Van Dam, the senior councilor, earned while serving as acting governor, and sues him in a court Cosby sets up himself. Chief Justice Lewis Morris rules against the governor. In 1733 Cosby removes him and names James DeLancey in his place. Morris’s friends decide they need a newspaper.

  2. The New-York Weekly Journal

    John Peter Zenger prints the first issue. He came to New York from the Palatinate in Germany as a boy of 12 or 13, and he learned the trade under William Bradford, the city’s first printer. The Journal comes out on Mondays and is backed by Morris, Van Dam and the lawyer James Alexander. It is the first paper in New York to oppose the governor, and it prints what the Gazette will not.

    A page of Zenger's New-York Weekly Journal, 23 September 1734, the kind of issue that put him in jail.
    A page of Zenger's New-York Weekly Journal, 23 September 1734, the kind of issue that put him in jail.. Photograph by XelaWho / John Peter Zenger, printer.
  3. Arrested for libel

    On the governor’s orders the sheriff arrests Zenger and takes him to the jail at City Hall on Wall Street. Bail is set at £400 with two more sureties of £200 each, far more than a printer can pay, and he stays in his cell. His wife Anna and his helpers keep the press running. Zenger gives them his instructions through a hole in the door, and the Journal keeps coming out.

  4. No indictment

    The grand jury will not indict him. The governor’s attorney general, Richard Bradley, files the charge of seditious libel himself, without a grand jury. Zenger waits in jail through the winter and into the spring. The Journal misses one issue and then keeps coming out.

  5. The lawyers are thrown out

    James Alexander and William Smith argue that DeLancey holds his seat on a governor’s order and has no right to it. DeLancey disbars both men on the spot. He assigns John Chambers to defend Zenger. Alexander and his friends send for the best lawyer in the colonies, Andrew Hamilton of Philadelphia, and Hamilton comes.

  6. Hamilton rises

    The trial opens in the courtroom on the second floor of City Hall. Hamilton shocks the room by admitting that Zenger printed the papers. His case is that the words are true, and that a true statement is no libel. DeLancey rules that truth is no defense. Hamilton turns from the bench and speaks to the jurors, who he says have the right to judge both the facts and the law.

  7. Not guilty

    The judge charges the jury to find only whether Zenger printed the papers. The jury leaves and returns in a short time. The clerk asks if Zenger is guilty, and foreman Thomas Hunt answers: “Not guilty.” The crowd in the courtroom answers with three cheers. Zenger is freed the next day.

    Zenger, A Brief Narrative (1736)there were three huzzas in the hall
  8. The same building

    In 1789 the old City Hall on Wall Street is rebuilt as Federal Hall, the first capitol of the United States. There the first Congress writes the Bill of Rights. Its First Amendment says Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech or of the press. The States ratify it in 1791, 56 years after the verdict.

The principals

The masthead of the New-York Weekly Journal, the paper Zenger printed, 23 September 1734. No free portrait of John Peter Zenger is available.Age 37
Printer, New-York Weekly JournalJohn Peter Zenger

German-born printer who learned his trade under William Bradford. He printed the Journal from 1733, sat in jail for over eight months, and walked free. New York named him its public printer in 1737. He died on 28 July 1746.

Andrew Hamilton of Philadelphia, who defended Zenger in 1735 (portrait by Adolf Ulrik Wertmüller, 1808).
Defense counsel, PhiladelphiaAndrew Hamilton

Scots-born lawyer, former attorney general of Pennsylvania and sitting speaker of its Assembly. He came to New York for Zenger and won the case in a day. Later he oversaw the building of the Pennsylvania State House, now Independence Hall.

James Alexander, the New York lawyer who helped found and write the New-York Weekly Journal.
Lawyer, Weekly Journal backerJames Alexander

Scots-born New York lawyer who helped found and write the Journal. He was disbarred for challenging the judge, and he is credited with the account of the trial published under Zenger’s name. His son became Revolutionary War general Lord Stirling.

William Cosby, Royal Governor of New York, 1732 to 1736 (portrait by Charles Jervas).
Royal Governor of New YorkWilliam Cosby

Army officer and former governor of Minorca who took charge of New York in 1732. He had the Journal’s printer arrested and lost the case. He died on 10 March 1736, seven months after the verdict.

By the numbers

5 Nov 1733the day the first issue of the New-York Weekly Journal came out
17 Nov 1734the day Zenger was arrested and sent to the City Hall jail
£400the bail set for a printer, more than he could pay
16 Apr 1735the day DeLancey disbarred both of Zenger’s first lawyers
1day the trial took, from the opening to the verdict
3cheers that rang through the hall when the verdict came
1789the year the Bill of Rights passed Congress in the same building
56 yearsfrom the verdict to the First Amendment’s ratification in 1791

Watch, listen, see

Films, photographs and first-hand accounts from across the web. Each opens in a new tab.

“It is not the cause of one poor printer, nor of New York alone, which you are now trying. No! It may in its consequence affect every free man that lives under a British government on the main of America. It is the best cause. It is the cause of liberty.”

Andrew Hamilton to the jury, 4 August 1735, from A Brief Narrative of the Case and Tryal of John Peter Zenger (1736)

After

Zenger went back to his press. In 1736 he printed A Brief Narrative of the Case and Tryal of John Peter Zenger, an account of the trial that was reprinted in the colonies and in England. In 1737 New York named him its public printer. He died on 28 July 1746. His widow Anna kept the shop going.

New York’s Common Council honored Andrew Hamilton with the freedom of the city, presented in a gold box. He went home to Philadelphia and died in 1741. His Zenger speech was printed again and again.

Hamilton’s words became the creed of the American press. The jury had decided that a printer could tell the truth about those in power. In 1791 the First Amendment protected the freedom of the press. Today the courtroom’s site at 26 Wall Street is Federal Hall National Memorial.

  1. Washington stands at the head of the Assembly Room as the delegates sign the Constitution, 17 September 1787 (Howard Chandler Christy, 1940).
    1787LibertyThe ConstitutionThirty-nine delegates signed the plan for a government of the people. It is the oldest written national constitution still in force.39signers
  2. Franklin’s kite experiment in a thunderstorm, with a son beside him: Currier & Ives lithograph, 1876
    1752InventionFranklin and the Lightning RodFranklin proposed the test, a kite repeated it in a Philadelphia storm, and a few feet of iron rod gave every house a way to survive lightning.6–8 ftof iron rod to save a house
  3. Declaration of Independence (John Trumbull, 1818–19)
    1776LibertyThe DeclarationFifty-six men signed their names to treason against the Crown and pledged their lives, fortunes and sacred honor.56signers
  4. Lincoln speaks at the dedication of the Soldiers' National Cemetery, 19 November 1863, as imagined in a Sherwood Lithograph Co. print of about 1905.
    1863LibertyA New Birth of FreedomLincoln spoke for about two minutes at Gettysburg and defined what the nation was for.272words

Free, with no ads. Support the museum →